I cannot count the number of times I’ve discussed this in the past.
If there is ever a situation that is guaranteed to cause social discord, it’s when people cannot understand what the other guy is saying. I grew up in a “bilingual” society (it was actually multi-lingual, but only unofficially so), and I can attest to this situation: it’s not just a principle.
This is especially true when dealing with officialdom in another country where English she is not spoke, but I have an ironclad rule about this: the onus is on you — the foreigner — to make the effort of comprehension, not the host country’s.
Somehow, we seem to have lost that, and foreigners seem to think that the host country has to make the effort to communicate with them in their home language, and not vice-versa.
Needless to say, then, this proclamation had me doing a Happy Dance:
The Justice Department just issued new guidance telling federal agencies to operate in English only. The guidance came out Thursday from the Justice Department under Attorney General Todd Blanche, and it backs up Trump’s executive order [EO 14224] in no uncertain terms. “Agencies should strive to operate solely in English,” the guidance said. Agencies are supposed to publish official correspondence, regulations, public announcements, applications, websites, educational resources, internal communications, and even artificial intelligence tools only in English.
Of course, as with so much bullshit of this kind, it began with Bill fucking Clinton:
Trump’s original order scrapped a policy former President Bill Clinton put in place in 2000 that pushed agencies to expand access to people with limited English skills. That order had left the existing multilingual services in place.
[20,00-word anti-Clinton rant deleted]
It’s all good stuff, this:
The new guidance goes a step further, establishing English as the default in all instances.
Translations can remain only where the law requires them or where an agency needs them to carry out its mission. National security and health care are the two examples the department gives. Everything else is going. Agencies are being told to find and eliminate all multilingual programs that don’t meet that test.
As the article points out, an EO is fine but it runs the risk of being overturned by a future EO — just as Trump’s has done with Clinton’s — and the reason why this has defaulted to executive orders is because Congress has never passed a law establishing English as our official State language.
Nor will they, especially now that Congress is being infested with assholes whose native language isn’t English.
The wisdom of having a single language of communication is so self-evident that nobody should have to justify it; but here we are, parked squarely inside Accommodationism Central, so it looks like this will never be resolved.