Taking A Stand

Now here’s a place I’d like to visit the next time I go Over There, because the owner seems to have the Right Stuff.

A pub boss has called last orders on customers in sportswear in a bid to drive out ‘chavs and roadmen with bumbags’ from his watering hole.
Landlord Brian Hoyle, who runs The Orange Tree in Hereford, has put a blanket ban on customers wearing hoodies, tracksuits and Stone Island clothing in his pub.
He is also barring under 21’s from the city centre pub at weekends due to youngsters being ‘unable to handle their booze’.

Needless to say, his dress code and age limit have aroused the anger of The Usual Suspects:

But the ban, which Hoyle says is aimed at making his watering hole a ‘proper’ Hereford pub again, has proved controversial among residents in the cathedral city.
Some of the residents have accused the policy of being ‘discriminatory’.

You see, this is what happens when you start ascribing motives to an ordinary word, used in its original (and correct) sense for centuries.

Let me say right now:  there’s nothing wrong with being discriminatory:  it’s a human trait that distinguishes civilized men from savages and animals, and helps us provide order in our world.

Sadly, of course, “discrimination” these days is used almost exclusively to demonize racial discrimination, which is not necessarily a Good Thing when applied purely as a measurement of skin color.  But historically, that is actually the least of the word’s many applications.  Here are a couple more.

When I say, for example, that I loathe “American” cheese (that orange paste stuff) and prefer to eat Jarlsberg, Cheddar or Emmenthaler, I am showing that I have a discriminating taste — just as is someone who would prefer to own and shoot a Colt Government over a Jennings Saturday Night Special, or prefers to own good knives made by Ken Onion over cheap brittle stuff made in China.  Nothing wrong with that.  Experience has taught you that stuff of inferior quality is not worth ownership or use.

When you prefer to invite people of your own sort to dinner parties, you’re being discriminating in your choice of friends — and once again, there is absolutely nothing wrong with that.

So of course, our worthy publican in the above story is setting his preferences — because over many years and much experience, he had discovered that people who dress a certain way and/or of a certain age tend to abuse his hospitality, so he wants to preclude them from coming in and, let it be known, spoiling things for people with manners, respect and proper attire.

Somebody needs to put an end to the loutish, boorish behavior of the younger generation, and he’s chosen to make a stand.

And good for him, say I.  If I were in his shoes, I would do precisely the same.


  1. “….people who dress a certain way and/or of a certain age tend to abuse his hospitality….”

    And of course the whiners natural response to such a statement is: “Not ALL people that dress that way are bad!”

    My response to such whiner would be a good crack across the yap.

    Just a guess mind you, but I believe maybe 90% or more of todays social issues could be solved instantly if more people got punched in the face.

  2. More to the point, he is selecting his target market, which sort of thing I’m sure you recall from your time in business.

  3. Another word which has become a negative is “judgmental”. The reason for this is very clear:

    They do not want you to exercise judgement.

    The ability to use good judgement is one of the very basic things that separates thinking human beings from animals. It is therefore a very bad thing. Why, you might arrive at the judgement that collectivist statists are assholes, and that would clearly be very bad.

  4. Blackwing,
    You’re right. Judgement is a design feature of the human being, not a flaw. Discrimination is used vastly more often for good than bad intentions. Discrimination and judgement prevented our ancestors from eating the berries that killed Thog the caveman. Discrimination helps us choose what we like and prefer in most instances.

    Judgement helps me decide who is capable of having a rational discussion and who is not.

    As far as the pub owner goes, I agree with him.


Comments are closed.