Barren Wasteland

Kim du Toit
March 19, 2008
9:00 AM EDT
· Society & Culture · Morality

In one of his best-ever columns, Peter Hitchens opens fire on the permissive, politically-correct culture, and the politicians who enabled it:

Our ancient culture was a forest that took a thousand years to grow and less than half a century to cut down. Now that the trees are all flattened, the people who massacred them find that they are shivering in a howling wilderness that they are powerless to restore to its former shape.

All the funny money “private finance initiatives” in the world, all the taxes they can raise, all the concrete and plastic they can buy, cannot rebuild a forest.

This is why nothing that they do works. The old mechanisms of loyalty and respect for authority – which these revolutionaries despised – are broken. They can shout all kinds of instructions at us, but nobody is really paying attention to anything they say.

They decree better schools and hospitals, and produce sinks of infection and ignorance, because they have destroyed conscientiousness and dutifulness, and sabotaged obedience.

They decree an end to “anti-social behaviour” but the loping packs of feral youths pay no attention, and carry on kicking people’s heads as if they were footballs.

Is this any surprise in a country whose leading minds have devoted the past half-century to dismantling absolute morality, the married family and the idea of punishment?

Hitchens is talking about modern-day Cool Britannia, of course, but the message is plain to us here in the United States as well. Only our innate conservatism has so far managed to hold off most of the miserable excesses of those “leading minds”—but it should be noted that the same process is nevertheless firmly embedded in our public school system, in our universities, and in our corporations.

As conservatives, we are accustomed to looking to the lessons of the past, to avoid making mistakes in the present—and those lessons, it should be noted, are often contemptuously dismissed as being “outdated” or “irrelevant in today’s world” by the Leading Minds.

Well, when it comes to the dismantling of our Western culture, we Americans no longer need to look to the past to see the results of earlier dismantlings: we need only look across the Atlantic to see the contemporary results.

Let’s be perfectly clear about the consequences of reckless destruction of our culture: as Hitchens points out, without cultural underpinnings to maintain standards and “absolute morality”, all that’s left are politicians’ thin decrees.

And decrees, as the miserable Brits are finding out, don’t work.


Comments

Bottom of Comments | Comment Form | Original Post

What is astounding to me is how many liberals look at Britain and say “it’s not THAT bad, they have free health care!”

I just cannot understand people that care so little for the soul of our society.

American Farmer | 3/19/2008 09:28 AM EDT |

We now have multiple generations of people whose “education” comes from the public school and the media.

Even if you can get them to listen to reason, you spend the majority of your time getting them to un-learn their preconcieved notions.

After 13 years in the government funded indoctrination mill I still have to question every reaction I have.  That is probably a good practice, regardless.  I still have the reaction to the idea of nice clothing and good food as being only for “people with more money than brains”.  I honestly believed that that knowing proper grammar was useless as the only thing important was that people knew what I was trying to say.

How much other garbage is in my brain that I have to clean out?

Cobar | 3/19/2008 11:17 AM EDT |

The decrees work fine ... if your goal is totalitarianism.

Watch “A Clockwork Orange” and “1984” back to back to get a clue.

Those kids kicking around people’s heads like footballs will be tomorrow’s government jack booted thugs.

kbarrett | 3/19/2008 11:52 AM EDT |

we need only look across the Atlantic to see the contemporary results.

Unfortunately, FAR too many of our “leaders” refuse to pay attention to the lessons from across the ocean, whether it is government, taxes, providing health care, crime, guns, etc., for some damn reason they think we’re immune to the mess from overseas.

308Mike | 3/19/2008 02:01 PM EDT |

Until he got to the “kicking heads” bit, I thought he was talking about the U.S.

arkythehun | 3/19/2008 02:36 PM EDT |

arkythehun, remember the “wilding” that was reported some years back in NYC?  Gangs of “Youts” (Thanx, LawDog) beating and raping?

‘Rat

Desertrat | 3/19/2008 03:54 PM EDT |

What is astounding to me is how many liberals look at Britain and say “it’s not THAT bad, they have free health care!”


John Derbyshire has it nailed:

Wherever there is a jackboot stomping on a human face there will be a well-heeled Western liberal to explain that the face does, after all, enjoy free health care and 100 percent literacy.

Kim du Toit | 3/19/2008 04:25 PM EDT |

In contrast, the New Hampshire House voted today, 279-19, to kill a bill that would have banned the carrying of firearms in the NH State House. So, any citizen, not prohibited from possessing a firearm under federal law, can openly carry a firearm in the State House - no permit or license required.

(Concealed carry requires a $10 license, no photo, fingerprinting, or training required)

Bruce in NH | 3/19/2008 04:57 PM EDT |

Reading about Great Britain’s cultural decline makes me sad.

As I recall seeing a few days ago, the Muslim faith (sic) in London is guilding the “mother of all mosques” right next to the Olympic park, event area to be on gaudy display for the 2012 Olympics.

I can easily imagine Prince Charles walking in with his prayer rug.

And watching the “football” thugs in Great Brittain and the rest of Europe is disgusting.

I have been going to car races throughout the South for the last 40 years, and I have never seen any fan behavior which remotely parallels the debauchery I frequently see (via the internet) at European soccer matches.

And then to tell you that you can’t defend yourself is just too much.

The inmates are running the assylum.

molonlabe28 | 3/19/2008 06:08 PM EDT |

And decrees, as the miserable Brits are finding out, don’t work.

It reminds me of Robin Williams explaining English Bobbies; “Stop! Or I’ll say ‘Stop’ again!”

Everwyck | 3/19/2008 06:08 PM EDT |

Hitchens is right. The demolition of rigid cultural traditions has left the door open to moral chaos. (One reason that capitalism is not conservative is that it destroys traditional social orders.)

The problem is that a lot of traditional culture which was not good. Compulsory religious belief, for instance. And it is hard to prove that any moral rule is valid purely by reason. Nor is instinct a reliable compass. Some things seem instinctively wrong, but others are wrong and yet do not set off the “squick” button; and some things set off some people’s squick buttons for reasons that others regard as mere bigotry.

Reconstructing a moral foundation from the ground up may be the greatest intellectual challenge our species has ever faced. If we cannot do it, all our technical skill may not matter.

The “web of trust” that sustains civilization requires morality.

Rich Rostrom | 3/19/2008 08:35 PM EDT |

Watch “A Clockwork Orange” and “1984” back to back to get a clue.

I’m still a believer in the answer proposed in “V for Vendetta”. The only way to truly regrow the forest is to demolish the city, plant the seeds, and give it time to grow. Anybody seen “I Am Legend”? If the pestilence of gummint were removed, and those immune to the disease move far from the heart of it, a decent society rebuilds. So many of these films show the possibility.

cmblake6 | 3/19/2008 08:43 PM EDT |

One all too real problem is the people who look across the Atlantic and completely fail to see what they are looking at.

“It isn’t so bad; at least they have free health care.”?

Yes, they do. And it’s worth every penny. But the number of people who examine it a completely fail to see the rot continually astonishes me.

C. S. P. Schofield | 3/19/2008 08:50 PM EDT |

After 13 years in the government funded indoctrination mill I still have to question every reaction I have.  That is probably a good practice, regardless.  I still have the reaction to the idea of nice clothing and good food as being only for “people with more money than brains”.  I honestly believed that that knowing proper grammar was useless as the only thing important was that people knew what I was trying to say.

How much other garbage is in my brain that I have to clean out?
Cobar | 3/20/2008 01:17 AM CCT |

I know what you mean.  As a ‘recovering liberal’ I often find my stinkin’ thinkin’ being challenged - an uncomfortable but necessary process.  At least now I’m willing to have my thinking challenged, whereas once I thought (like many leftists) that I had it all nailed.  After a very uncomfortable experience a few years ago which taught me I know nothing, I’m still relearning hand over fist.  Sites like this are a great service.

Morris | 3/19/2008 09:03 PM EDT |

Rat,

The only “wilding” I recall was a beating and raping of a woman in Central Park by six teenagers about 20 years ago and some gang fighting.

I cannot say it surprises me and we’ve definitely need to improve.  At least (unfortunately the very least) when it does happen in the U.S., it makes the news.  In the U.K., it’s not even a blip on the cultural radar.

arkythehun | 3/20/2008 12:45 AM EDT |

We see the problem. Can we even discuss what the solutions are?

USMC-1983 | 3/20/2008 08:04 AM EDT |

Wilding was bad for tourism, which led to shifting around of police presence.  NYC cops aren’t given to, “Stop!  If you don’t stop, I’ll say ‘Stop!’ again!”

It looks to me as though those who are responsible for laws and for maintenance of the peace and security of communities in England have pretty much abdicated.  They’ve given up, given the streets over to the evil segments of society…

We have similar attitudes in the U.S.  Decades back, there was a rash of muggings in city parks at night in Austin, Texas.  The city council’s solution was to impose a curfew on public use of the parks.  This was just another of the many reasons I voted with my feet and left Austin.

Desertrat | 3/20/2008 09:59 AM EDT |

We see the problem. Can we even discuss what the solutions are?
USMC-1983 |

So one would hope.  However, if you accept that there is no objectively real thing behind the term ‘Society,’ but only case by case a vector sum of attitudes and emotions held by an entire population, then the likelihood of achieving an intentional change in the force and direction of the attitude toward, say, personal responsibility, is nearly zero.
It can be done, but the techniques used by the inspired heroes who got us this far - Mussolini, Roosevelt, Mao, many others - are tedious and expensive.
My own approach has been to factor Society down to include just me, and attempt to reform that.  Not much progress to report, yet, but we’re under way.
.

stencil | 3/20/2008 11:08 AM EDT |

when it does happen in the U.S., it makes the news.  In the U.K., it’s not even a blip on the cultural radar.

Arky, That isn’t at all true. The kickings,the stabbings the killings are given lots of space and it’s something you can’t get away from here.

Gangs of 15 yr olds and even younger.
Most recently a young women was kicked to death while trying to comfort her boyfriend who’d just been beaten by the same gang.

Prisons here are overloaded (the say) and so prisoners are being released to make room for newer ones.  There just isn’t enuff space here to detail it all.  But trust me, is is given lots of coverage.

The odd thing is, most Brits I talk to are horrified at the American attitude toward gun ownership.  Ant these folks are totally defensless.

jdpeiper | 3/21/2008 09:23 AM EDT |

It looks to me as though those who are responsible for laws and for maintenance of the peace and security of communities in England have pretty much abdicated.  They’ve given up, given the streets over to the evil segments of society…

Courtesy of the socialist educators and the feeeeeel good social programs.

My own approach has been to factor Society down to include just me, and attempt to reform that.  Not much progress to report, yet, but we’re under way.

THIS is all we CAN do. But we must try. Good on ya for at least trying.

Prisons here are overloaded (the say) and so prisoners are being released to make room for newer ones.

So what we do is make prison so horrendous people do not WANT to go there for “three hots and a cot”. We do a Joe Arpaio(?), and make it PUNISHMENT, not vacation. Capital crimes? Life with no chance of parole? Death penalty, carried out within one year. There have been a FEW who’ve actually turned out innocent, but not bloody many. And with modern science, we’ve gotten past that problem. We’ve got stuff they didn’t have back then, like DNA for example. You can’t bullshit your way around that.

cmblake6 | 3/21/2008 10:08 AM EDT |

Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.