Here’s the setup:
The Rock ‘N Roll Hall Of Fame (a stupid concept all by itself, but we can discuss that some other time) has decided that they’ve cocked the whole thing up, and want to start from scratch. In other words, the HoF is completely empty and needs refilling. And in their magnificent wisdom, they’ve given you the job of deciding the inductees, with the following restrictions:
The inductees must be genuine rock ‘n rollers: no jazz, no country and only a few exceptions for the blues can be made. The inductions happen every year. The list of inductees may not be longer than twenty in any given year.
I’ll start the ball rolling with my thoughts on the topic. I’m going to do it more or less historically, just to make things simple (I think), and they’re in no specific order.
Year 1, in which I list the early rock-and-rollers, but leave the R&B vocal bands and singers for next year:
- Elvis Presley
- Bill Haley and the Comets
- Albert King
- Chuck Berry
- Buddy Holly & The Crickets
- B.B. King (one of the “blues exceptions”, because denying B.B. the honor would be sacrilege)
- Jerry Lee Lewis
- Little Richard
- The Everly Brothers
- Frankie Lymon and the Teenagers
- Del Shannon
- Carl Perkins
- Bo Diddley
- Roy Orbison
- Fats Domino
- Ricky Nelson
- Gene Vincent
- James Brown
- Duane Eddy
- Link Wray
Feel free to argue the selection, or tell me about notable exclusions from the list. One last thought: I’ve excluded the “influencers” (e.g. Muddy Waters and all those Depression-era blues artists), because otherwise we’ll be here all day.
This could get ugly, I can see. I don’t want to get all gamma about this, but it seems to me that your definition of Rock & Roll might be a little wide. For example, I’d question the inclusion of:
The Everly Brothers
Frankie Lymon and the Teenagers
Del Shannon
Roy Orbison
Ricky Nelson
as being Rock & Roll, strictly defined. Including that bunch opens you up to Phil Spector[*], Motown, and a whole lot more … e.g. Carole King[*] and the whole Brill Building cabal, Paul Simon fercrissake. Were the Beatles Rock & Roll? You could have a serious argument.
This probably reflects that I was raised on hardcore Detroit Rock & Roll … Amboy Dukes (Nuge), Mitch Ryder, MC5, Bob Seger, Iggy Pop, Frost, etc.
That said, I’m in violent agreement with the others on your list and I’m eager to see what your ’60 – ’65 picks are going to be as that’s where the tree of rock really gets gnarly.
[*] Phil and Carole might could get in based solely on “He Hit Me and It Felt Like a Kiss”, something that doesn’t get a lot of Spotify play.